Store brands vs. name brands: which ones are worth your money at the grocery store

Grocery costs are up, and the strain of stretched food budgets is being felt nationwide. Many shoppers are rethinking their shopping strategies and adjusting shopping patterns and weekly menus as a result.

If you’ve ever stared at a shelf wondering whether to grab a $2 store-brand cereal or its $4 name-brand counterpart, you’re not alone. When is it worth it to splurge on the name brand, and when will the store brand do just as well? As it turns out, the answer isn’t always straightforward.  

What are store brands, anyway?

Store brands, also called private labels, have grown in popularity—and for good reason. They’re usually 20–50% cheaper than name brands, sometimes even more. (Think Walmart’s Great Value, Target’s up&up, and Costco’s Kirkland Signature.) 

But does cheaper mean lower quality? Not always.

Where store brands shine

For staples like pasta, rice, canned vegetables, and frozen foods, store brands often match or come close to name-brand taste and quality. Supermarkets know shoppers are price-conscious, so many invest in premium recipes for their private-label items. Customer taste tests often show minimal differences between brands and their store-brand versions.

When name brands may be worth it

Some products rely heavily on proprietary formulas, unique flavors, or trusted reputations. Think of your favorite breakfast cereal, specialty sauces, or premium snack foods. Name brands often justify the extra cost with consistent quality and trusted ingredients, which can matter for baby formula, certain dairy products, and allergy-sensitive items.

Similarly, if you’ve tried the store-brand version and just prefer the name brand, go for it!

Smart shopping tips

1. Compare ingredients and nutrition labels — name-brand products can often be swapped for similar, less expensive store brands.
   
2. Buy store brands for basics — milk, pasta, rice, beans, and frozen veggies are almost always safe bets.
   
3. Use name brands strategically—for items where taste or texture really matters, such as ice cream, yogurt, bread, or cereal.
   
4. Mix and match — buy store-brand staples while keeping a few of your must-have name-brand favorites in your cart.
   

Bottom line

Store brands can save you a bundle without sacrificing quality, especially for everyday staples. Name brands still have their place for specialty items or products you can’t compromise on. A little label-reading and strategic swaps can make your grocery budget go further — without sacrificing taste.

Links on this page may be affiliate links, for which the site earns a small commission, but the price for you is the same