"Reasons why I don't order from here anymore. These prices are ridiculous." That Reddit post came with a photo: a Shaq-a-Roni pizza at $17.99, an Epic Pepperoni-Stuffed Crust pizza at $18.99, and after a $2 coupon, $8.99 in delivery fees, and $3.14 in taxes, a total of $47.11 for two pizzas before tipping the driver. The customer wasn't ranting about a bad experience. They were doing math. Papa John's built its identity on a simple slogan: [...]













