New York has lost another deeply rooted neighborhood restaurant just as autumn’s closure list keeps growing. Errol’s Caribbean Delights announced October 24 as its final day, ending 25 years of feeding Brooklyn’s Little Caribbean as its longtime owners retire.
Jamaican immigrant Errol Miller opened the business in 2001 as Errol’s Bakery and Catering at Flatbush Avenue and Hawthorne Street. What began with hard dough bread, buns and pastries grew into a compact restaurant serving the Jamaican meals its neighbors craved, with the business later taking the name Errol’s Caribbean Delights.
A taste of home in Little Caribbean
The menu moved easily between bakery counter and steam table. Customers came for coco bread, fruit cake and other Caribbean baked goods, then stayed for oxtail, curried goat, jerk chicken and escovitch fish. Sorrel mixed with ginger beer offered another taste of the islands, while Jamaican breakfasts turned the storefront into a familiar morning stop. The combination let shoppers pick up bread for home, a hot plate for dinner and a celebration cake from the same family-run counter. That range made Errol’s useful on weekdays and essential on holidays.
Food was only part of the attachment. Regulars described Errol’s as a place that felt like home and carried the spirit of Jamaica into everyday life in Flatbush. Some had been eating there since high school; others relied on its decorated cakes for baby showers and family celebrations. In a neighborhood rich with West Indian restaurants, customers still considered this corner shop one of its defining staples.
A retirement earned over decades
Workers said the owners, both in their 80s, were ready to retire and spend more time with their grandchildren. A business partner had also died a little more than a year before the closing. The decision followed years of work and one earlier fight to stay: Errol’s faced eviction in 2016 and 2017 before community pressure helped secure another lease.
That history explains why the farewell landed so hard. Neighbors once organized to keep the bakery in place, and the new agreement gave it nearly another decade on Flatbush Avenue. Its survival also showed how organized neighbors could buy a threatened small business precious time. As the final date approached, customers returned for last meals, flowers and handwritten cards—small gestures for owners who had fed them through countless ordinary days.
Errol’s leaves behind more than an empty storefront. It showed how a bakery can become a cultural anchor, preserving familiar flavors while giving immigrants and their children a place that reflected home. After 25 years, Little Caribbean has lost a shop woven into its meals, milestones and memories.
Links on this page may be affiliate links, for which the site earns a small commission, but the price for you is the same
Leave a Comment