Ohio has said goodbye to several longtime dining favorites, and Delaware has now lost a downtown pub that served the community for 22 years. Old Bag of Nails Pub closed its location at 66 N. Sandusky Street after service on October 11, 2026.
The restaurant opened in 2004, years before downtown Delaware developed its current concentration of dining and entertainment businesses. It became a familiar stop for Ohio Wesleyan University families, downtown workers, longtime residents, and visitors looking for a casual meal in the center of town.

A lease ended the 22-year run
The closure followed unsuccessful efforts to secure the restaurantโs future in the building. The pubโs original 20-year lease expired in 2024, and the Delaware location continued on a month-to-month arrangement while the company sought a longer-term deal.
Old Bag of Nails said it could not reach an agreement with the landlord that would allow operations to continue. Company leadership also said an offer to purchase the building was not accepted. Without long-term control of the property, investing in needed improvements no longer made business sense.
The decision was location-specific. Old Bag of Nails continues to operate pubs elsewhere in Ohio and Michigan, and the company has left open the possibility of returning to Delaware if another suitable opportunity appears.
Fish and chips made it a local favorite
The regional restaurant group traces its beginnings to 1996, when founders Michael and Tara Purdum converted part of an old hardware store in Worthington into a neighborhood pub. The rustic surroundings inspired the name, while the kitchenโs fish and chips grew into the brandโs signature dish.
In Delaware, customers came back for that crisp fried fish as well as burgers, wings, lobster rolls, meatloaf sandwiches, grilled fish tacos, fried mushrooms, and spinach salad. The broad comfort-food menu made the restaurant easy to choose for a family dinner, a casual lunch, or a pint with friends.
What patrons mourned was more than one menu item. Regulars described bringing children and, years later, grandchildren to the same tables. That continuity helped turn the pub into the sort of dependable neighborhood place where staff recognized familiar faces and ordinary meals became family traditions.
Its departure leaves a conspicuous gap on North Sandusky Street. Other Old Bag of Nails locations can still serve the famous fish and chips, but Delawareโs 22-year chapter belonged to the employees and customers who made this particular pub part of downtown life. For a generation, its dining room offered something harder to replace than a plate: a dependable meeting place woven into the weekly rhythm of downtown.
Links on this page may be affiliate links, for which the site earns a small commission, but the price for you is the same


Leave a Comment