So, after a whole lot of tasting, I’ve put together a list of the absolute best cashew butter brands out there. So, sit back, grab a spoon, and let’s dig into the nutty details!
How to choose the best cashew butter
There are a few different kinds of cashew butter: salted, unsalted, raw, roasted, sweetened, or unsweetened. Raw cashew butter is milder in taste, slightly more nutritious, and usually more expensive than roasted varieties.
So, when choosing the best cashew butter, there are several factors that play into this nutty equation.
I used a five-pronged approach to evaluate each brand:
- Ingredients: The simpler, the better. I gave top points to brands that kept things simple with just one ingredient: raw or roasted cashews. Anything beyond that, like added oils or salt, led to a slight deduction in scores.
- Consumer feedback: Brands that had a strong following of satisfied customers soared to the top. I scoured through online reviews, chatted with friends, and used my own taste tests.
- Nutrition: Brands that offered a good balance between those heart-healthy fats, a smidge of protein, and minimal sugar clinched higher scores. Nut butter that not only tastes amazing but also nourishes your body? Sign me up!
- Track record: Brands with a solid history of consistent quality, reliability, and availability got a big thumbs-up from me.
- Price: I factored in the price point as well. While I’m totally ready to invest in a jar of pure cashew heaven, it’s also important to make sure the quality matches the price tag.
Top 11 cashew butter brands
|Overall Rank||Brand (click link to buy)||Type||Best for|
|1||Artisana Organics Raw Cashew Butter||Raw, unsalted||Overall|
|2||Vör All Natural Cashew Butter||Roasted, unsalted||Runner-up|
|3||365 by Whole Foods Market Creamy Cashew Butter||Roasted, unsalted||N/A|
|4||Jiva Organics Raw Cashew Butter||Raw, unsalted||Texture|
|5||Trader Joe’s Creamy Salted Cashew Butter||Roasted, salted||Budget|
|6||Spread The Love Basic Cashew Butter||Raw, unsalted||N/A|
|7||Maisie Jane’s Organic Cashew Butter||Roasted, unsalted||N/A|
|8||Kevala Cashew Butter||Roasted, unsalted||Value|
|9||Octonuts Roasted Sea Salt Caramel Cashew Butter||Roasted, flavored (salted & sweetened)||Flavored|
|10||Once Again Organic Creamy Cashew Butter||Raw, unsalted||N/A|
|11||Aplenty Vanilla Cashew Butter||Raw, vanilla (salted & sweetened)||Spreading|
#1 Best Overall: Artisana Organics Raw Cashew Butter
Artisana Organics Raw Cashew Butter ticks all of the boxes! It’s creamy, smooth, and made with just one ingredient: raw organic cashews. Spread it on toast, swirl it into your oatmeal, or dip your fruit in it.
Ingredients: Raw Organic Cashews
#2 Runner-Up: Vör All Natural Cashew Butter
If simplicity had a name, it’d be Vör. This all-natural, unsalted cashew butter is all about preserving the pure cashew flavor. Plus, it’s so velvety that it practically melts in your mouth.
Ingredients: Roasted Cashews
#3 365 by Whole Foods Market Creamy Cashew Butter
Trust Whole Foods to deliver! Creamy, dreamy, and oh-so-delicious, this cashew butter is a winner with no added sugar.
Ingredients: Dry Roasted Cashews, Expeller Pressed Safflower Seed Oil
#4 Best Texture: Jiva Organics Raw Cashew Butter
I love Jiva Organics Raw Cashew Butter for its super smooth texture. It’s not oily like some other brands and you don’t get that separation. Pure and simple – it’s like eating cashews in spreadable form.
Ingredients: Raw Organic Cashews
#5 Spread The Love Basic Cashew Butter
Handcrafted in small batches, Spread The Love’s Basic Cashew Butter screams premium quality and freshness. The dedication to crafting this spread really shines through in every spoonful.
#6 Best Budget: Trader Joe’s Creamy Salted Cashew Butter
For those of us who appreciate a good deal, Trader Joe’s comes to the rescue. Creamy, slightly salted, and wallet-friendly – what more could we ask for?
Ingredients: Dry Roasted Cashews, Sunflower Oil, Sea Salt, Less than 1% Dry Roasted Almonds
#7 Maisie Jane’s Organic Cashew Butter
Organic and oh-so-luscious, Maisie Jane’s Cashew Butter is a simple, natural, creamy, roasted cashew butter. Find it at your local grocery store, Whole Foods, or online.
Ingredients: Organic Dry Roasted Cashews
#8 Best Value: Kevala Cashew Butter
For the true cashew butter aficionados who know one jar is never enough, Kevala comes to the rescue with a whopping 3.5 lb container. It’s value-packed, meaning you’ll never run out of your favorite spread.
Ingredients: Dry Roasted Cashews
#9 Best Flavor: Octonuts Roasted Sea Salt Caramel Cashew Butter
Octonuts takes cashew butter to a whole new level. It tastes like salted caramel, and it’s sweetened with coconut sugar. It’s like dessert in a jar!
Ingredients: Cashews, Coconut Sugar, Natural Flavor, Sea Salt.
#10 Once Again Organic Creamy Cashew Butter
Another organic contender on the list, Once Again’s Creamy Cashew Butter combines quality ingredients with a smooth texture that’s perfect for spreading, dipping, or devouring by the spoonful.
Ingredients: Organic Cashews, Organic Sunflower Oil
#11 Easy to Spread: Aplenty Vanilla Cashew Butter
Last but not least, this Amazon brand brings a twist with their sweetened vanilla-infused cashew butter. It also contains palm oil, making it easy to spread on toast or bread.
Ingredients: Cashews, Cane Sugar, Sustainably Sourced Palm Oil, Sunflower Oil, Vanilla Extract, Natural Flavor, Sea Salt, Cinnamon.
Comparing cashew butter brands nutrition facts
These cashew butter brands have slightly different nutritional profiles based on how they were processed and whether they have added sugar, salt, or vegetable oils in their ingredients.
Roasted cashews have slightly more calories and fat compared to raw cashews, and some of the vitamins and minerals can be lost during the heating/roasting process.
Here are each of the cashew butter brand’s nutrition facts, straight from their labels:
|Per 2 Tbsp. (30-32g)||Calories||Fat (g)||Sodium (mg)||Carbs (g)||Fiber (g)||Sugar (added sugars) (g)||Protein (g)|
|Artisana Organics Raw Cashew Butter||180||14||0||10||1||2 (0)||6|
|Vör All Natural Cashew Butter||160||13||0||9||1||1 (0)||4|
|365 by Whole Foods Market Creamy Cashew Butter||190||17||0||9||<1||1 (0)||4|
|Jiva Organics Raw Cashew Butter||151||13||2||5||1||1 (0)||5|
|Trader Joe’s Creamy Salted Cashew Butter||190||16||100||9||1||1 (0)||4|
|Spread The Love Basic Cashew Butter||190||17||0||9||1||1 (0)||4|
|Kevala Cashew Butter||185||15||5||8||1||0||5|
|Maisie Jane’s Organic Cashew Butter||169||14||3||6||1||1.7 (0)||5|
|Octonuts Roasted Sea Salt Caramel Cashew Butter||190||15||200||11||1||5 (3)||4|
|Once Again Organic Creamy Cashew Butter||190||15||5||8||1||2 (0)||5|
|Aplenty Vanilla Cashew Butter||170||13||70||12||1||5 (4)||5|