Pennsylvania has lost another beloved dining landmark, and this one carried nearly a century of restaurant history. The Conewago Inn in Manchester closed after its final service on November 14, 2026, ending Tom and Sharon Robertsโ 23-year chapter as owners of the historic York County property.
The Roberts family had placed the inn and its established restaurant business on the market as the couple prepared to retire. The $1.25 million offering included the real estate, liquor license and business assets, but the inn ultimately announced a firm final day. For regulars, the farewell meant losing far more than a place for dinner: it closed a rustic gathering spot where local history, family celebrations and neighborhood friendships shared the same rooms.

A restaurant with roots in the 1920s
The main log structure dates to 1860 and once served as a farmhouse and stagecoach stop along York Haven Road. It became an inn during the 1920s, briefly operating as the Creekside Inn before taking the Conewago name from the nearby creek. Generations of diners arrived long before the Roberts family took over, making the restaurantโs story much older than its most recent ownership.
That past remained visible inside. Guests could eat in a log-cabin-style dining room, settle into an all-season room with retractable windows or move into the pub for a drink and a game of pool. The combination felt more like a rambling country retreat than a standardized dining room.
Crab, prime rib and a York County tradition
The menu blended seafood, steakhouse favorites and hearty pub fare. Conewago crab dip, cream of crab and asparagus soup, steamed clams, steaks and weekend prime rib gave special-occasion diners plenty to choose from. In warmer months, turtle soup connected the kitchen to a longstanding York County tradition. The pub added wings, cold beer and casual specials to the mix.
Customers loved that range because the inn could be several places at once. It worked for an anniversary dinner, a family lunch, a late drink or an easy night with friends. Its location near Conewago Creek and an old iron bridge also gave every visit a strong sense of place. Its own mottoโโLet our family take care of yoursโโcaptured the sense of familiarity the Roberts family cultivated over more than two decades.
Retirement explains why the owners were ready to step away, but it does not make the loss feel smaller. The building may eventually begin another chapter under new ownership. What ended in November was the version generations knew: a historic Pennsylvania inn where old timbers, regional recipes and 23 years of one familyโs hospitality turned ordinary meals into local tradition.
Links on this page may be affiliate links, for which the site earns a small commission, but the price for you is the same


Leave a Comment