Pumpkin Seed Oil vs Butter: Which is Better?

Both pumpkin seed oil and butter possess a rich, velvety texture that can elevate the simplest of dishes to new heights of flavor. Yet, they couldn’t be more different in their origins, compositions, and potential benefits. 

So, which is better? Let’s find out!

Comparing pumpkin seed oil vs butter

	Pumpkin seed oil	Butter
Solid or Liquid?	Liquid	Solid
Smoke Point (Fahrenheit)	320 degrees	300-350 degrees
Primary Fat	Polyunsaturated	Saturated
Taste	Intense, nutty	Buttery
Good for Cooking…	Raw, low heat	Raw, low heat
Allergens	Pumpkin seed	Lactose, casein
Gluten-free?	Yes	Yes
Keto?	Yes	Yes
Paleo?	Yes	No
Vegan?	Yes	No

Differences between pumpkin seed oil and butter

Pumpkin seed oil and butter are fundamentally different in their origin, extraction, and processing methods.

Pumpkin seed oil is a type of oil made from roasted (or raw, unroasted) and pressed pumpkin seeds, resulting in a dark green oil with a rich nutty flavor. On the other hand, butter is a dairy product obtained by churning cream or milk, usually from cows.

The main distinction lies in their fat content and composition. Pumpkin seed oil is primarily composed of unsaturated fats, including monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats, while butter is predominantly saturated fat. This impacts their nutritional profiles and the way they behave in cooking. I’ll explain both, starting with cooking!

Baking and cooking with pumpkin seed oil vs butter

When it comes to cooking and baking, understanding the smoke point is crucial. Pumpkin seed oil has a low smoke point, making it unsuitable for high-heat cooking methods like frying or sautéing. However, its robust flavor makes it an excellent addition to dressings, marinades, and drizzles. Use pumpkin seed oil to elevate salads, roasted vegetables, or even as a finishing touch on soups and pastas.

Butter, with its higher smoke point, lends itself well to various cooking techniques. From sautéing to baking, butter adds richness and depth to dishes. It’s perfect for classic recipes like buttery mashed potatoes, flaky pastries, and indulgent sauces. Additionally, butter’s creamy consistency makes it a delightful choice for spreading on warm toast or melting over steamed vegetables.

Can pumpkin seed oil and butter be substituted for each other?

Because pumpkin seed oil and butter are so different, it’s hard to substitute them for each other.

Remember, pumpkin seed oil is not suitable for high-heat cooking, so it’s not an ideal substitute for butter in frying or baking applications that require solid fat. Similarly, butter’s creamy texture may not work well as a direct substitute for pumpkin seed oil in salad dressings or as a finishing oil.

In my experience, macadamia oil work betters as a raw cooking substitute for butter, and walnut oil may be a better replacement for pumpkin seed oil.

Nutrition: Pumpkin seed oil vs butter

Made pure from 100% pumpkin seeds, pumpkin seed oil is rich in essential fatty acids, such as omega-3 and omega-6, which are beneficial for heart health. It also contains vitamin E, antioxidants, and minerals like zinc and magnesium.

Butter, while high in saturated fat, provides fat-soluble vitamins like A, D, E, and K2, as well as trace amounts of minerals.

It’s worth noting that both pumpkin seed oil and butter are calorie-dense (pumpkin seed oil more so), so moderation is key. As with any ingredient, incorporating them into a well-balanced diet is essential for reaping their benefits while maintaining overall health.

Per tablespoon (15mL)	Pumpkin seed oil	Butter
Calories	130	102
Polyunsaturated	7.5 g	0.4
Monounsaturated	6 g	3.0 g
Saturated	1.5 g	7.3 g
Trans	0 g	0.5 g
Total Fat	14 g	14.2 g
Cholesterol	0	30.5 mg

The primary fat source is bolded.

How to store pumpkin seed oil and butter

Pumpkin seed oil is delicate and susceptible to degradation when exposed to light, heat, and oxygen. To maintain its freshness and quality, pumpkin seed oil should be stored in a cool area away from direct sunlight. Light can cause oxidation and lead to rancidity, so a dark pantry or cupboard is ideal.

Pumpkin seed oil has a limited shelf life, usually ranging from 6 to 12 months. Be mindful of the expiration date and use it within the recommended timeframe for optimal flavor.

Butter has a higher fat content and contains water, making its storage requirements slightly different. Butter should be stored in the refrigerator to maintain its freshness and prevent spoilage. I recommend keeping it in an airtight container or wrap it tightly in wax paper or aluminum foil.

Butter can go rancid over time, so it’s essential to check for any off odors or discoloration before using it. When properly stored, butter can typically last for a few weeks in the refrigerator.

Pumpkin seed oil vs butter: Which is better

In the battle of pumpkin seed oil vs butter, choosing a winner ultimately comes down to personal preference and the intended use. Pumpkin seed oil brings a unique nutty flavor and a range of nutritional benefits to the table, making it a fantastic choice for dressings and drizzles. Meanwhile, butter’s creamy richness adds unparalleled decadence to cooking and baking endeavors.

So, the final verdict? While both have their distinct merits, I find myself leaning towards butter. Its versatility, higher smoke point, and ability to enhance a wide array of recipes make it an indispensable ingredient in my kitchen. However, don’t be afraid to experiment and embrace the goodness of pumpkin seed oil when you’re looking for a flavorful twist or a health-conscious alternative!

FAQs

Links on this page may be affiliate links, for which the site earns a small commission, but the price for you is the same