New Jersey has lost three more neighborhood dining spots in recent weeks. In just a few September weeks, a longtime Shore pizzeria, a coastal kitchen and a family-run café each served their last customers. All were independently owned local spots.
Their menus could hardly have been more different. But each had become familiar to the people who stopped in for a slice, a seafood dinner or a morning coffee. Here’s what New Jersey diners are saying goodbye to. The restaurants all announced their closures in September. Their years in business ranged from two to more than thirty. Their food and stories were as different as their New Jersey hometowns.
Serpico’s Pizzeria and Restaurant in Allenhurst
The pizzeria closed in late September after more than 30 years, according to Patch. The restaurant first opened in 1994. It served pizza and pasta, along with calzones and sandwiches. Customers visited for everyday meals and important family milestones. The farewell thanked regulars for their support throughout the years.
Founded by Anthony Serpico and Charles Clarke in November 1994, the restaurant served generations of local customers. The owners’ message recalled first days of school, Thanksgiving visits and graduations. It was a place people returned to over the years, sometimes bringing their own children along.
Saltwater Bar and Kitchen in Highlands
Saltwater Bar and Kitchen closed in late September after two years in Highlands. The Bay Avenue restaurant was opened by chef Mike Metzner, and its relaxed coastal atmosphere reflected its Jersey Shore location. It was a young business compared with the longtime pizzeria in Allenhurst.
It served seafood and comfort food, including lobster fried rice. The menu also offered clam chowder, Nashville hot chicken and seared scallops. The kitchen mixed seafood with comfort-food twists, and the owner thanked guests and staff in a farewell announcement. New Jersey 101.5 reported that diners responded with sadness and appreciation, including kind words about the staff.
Rockin’ Roots in Hillsdale
Rockin’ Roots served its last customers on September 26, 2026, after seven years. The family-run café offered healthy meals, fresh juices, smoothies, protein bowls and coffee. It was founded to make nutritious food accessible to neighbors at a fair price. The owners described customers as friends.
In a farewell message covered by Patch, the owners recalled watching customers’ children grow up over the years and seeing local students work behind the counter. That sense of connection mattered as much as the menu. Their announcement did not identify a specific reason for the closure, but it encouraged people to continue supporting local businesses.
Links on this page may be affiliate links, for which the site earns a small commission, but the price for you is the same
Leave a Comment