This unique product stemming from one of the greatest culinary countries ever, Italy, is something you definitely want to check out!
I’m talking about amaretto extract, a wonderful flavoring agent that can offer a really unique twist to many of your dishes! It’s often used in baking and confectionery, adding a nutty, sweet, and slightly bitter taste to the many things you can pair it with.
Amaretto extract has a distinct nutty flavor that’s similar to almond extract, although it still has its own unique tastes, including a slight bitterness – amaretto roughly translates to “a little bitter” in Italian. We’ll talk more about the differences between this and almond extract later!
As great and unique as it is, you want to be sure that you’re using a high-quality and proper amaretto extract, as not just every product is worth your money! And that’s exactly what we’ll discuss in this article – we’ve tested many amaretto extracts in order to give you the best ones, ranking them so that you can avoid using any bad ones!
Let’s check them out!
What is amaretto extract?
Amaretto extract is a liquid with a very concentrated flavor made from the bitter almond-like kernels of apricot pits and sometimes including or exclusively made from peach pits – it also sometimes includes almonds. These ingredients are added into alcohol, along with sweeteners such as honey or sugar, which are all then left to process.
The alcohol, which is usually unflavored vodka, extracts all the delicious flavors from all the ingredients that are added. Then, after a long period of time, it’s filtered, leaving us with amaretto extract!
It has a very powerful and distinct flavor, which means that you should be careful with it – don’t go dumping it into everything, but rather start with just a little and add as desired. A couple drops go a long way with amaretto extract!
Key differences between amaretto extract and almond extract
The biggest difference between amaretto extract and almond extract is taste. But it’s subtle! You see, the first thing you’ll notice when tasting amaretto extract is that it boasts a nutty flavor that’s similar to almond extract, with both extracts lending their delicious and nutty characteristics to many dishes!
However, amaretto extract has a distinct bitter flavor that comes from the apricot or peach pits that it’s often made from – in fact, despite the almond flavor, amaretto extract doesn’t always contain almonds!
You may also find cherry undertones in your amaretto extract depending on the brand and ingredients used, which you won’t find in almond extract.
Almond extract usually uses bitter almond oil, which has a stronger almond flavor. However, it doesn’t have the same bitter flavor that amaretto extract does. Plus, amaretto extract often has things like sugar and honey added that add a sweetness to it.
So yes, you can use these interchangeably – just be aware of the different flavor profiles!
How to use amaretto extract in recipes
Amaretto extract is awesome for baking, as well as for adding flavor to things like tea, coffee, hot chocolate, and more!
Just a few drops of it will add a nutty and sweet yet slightly bitter taste, adding a new dimension to your dish! It’s popular in cookies, muffins, and cakes, and is also a great substitute for amaretto liqueur…
OliveNation, which is a brand we’ll talk about later, recommends using ¼ to ½ a teaspoon of amaretto extract for every 2 tablespoons of amaretto liqueur – that shows you how strong amaretto extract is!
Plus, substituting it for the liqueur in bakes makes your dish free of alcohol as the content in the extract will evaporate when you bake with it!
Otherwise, start with about ½ a teaspoon for general flavoring, then slowly add more until you get your desired taste – remember, a little goes a long way here!
3 great recipes to use your amaretto extract
With amaretto providing such a unique flavor, you can use it in both recipes that call for amaretto extract and recipes that call for almond extract, as amaretto extract may be a delicious substitute:
- Cherry amaretto ice cream: Not only is this ice cream delicious, but it’s dairy-free as well! It uses real blended cherries and coconut milk to create an amazing dessert that you’ll have trouble putting down! The recipe creates an amaretto flavor using almond extract and some other ingredients, but you can simply replace the almond extract with amaretto extract to enhance the amaretto flavor even more!
- Almond flour pancakes: This recipe is great if you want to level-up your breakfast! These pancakes use almond flour to provide a nutty twist, and calls for almond extract to further enhance the taste. However, you can substitute it for amaretto extract to create a slightly new flavor profile!
- Almond flour cake: This cake boasts delicious almond and vanilla flavors – and with amaretto extract, you can add a delicious twist to this great recipe! I recommend keeping the almond extract it calls for, and adding the same amount of amaretto extract in addition. This way, you get extra almond flavor with some unique undertones!
How to choose the best amaretto extract
Finding the best amaretto extract is a bit of trial-and-error, along with requiring some detective work. But don’t worry, we’ve done all that for you! We also created this list of criteria to filter out all the bad amaretto extracts, with only the great ones getting through:
- Ingredients: We want to avoid artificial ingredients, including flavoring and colors. The natural stuff always gets the best tastes when done right, and is the best for your body!
- Consumer feedback: It’s important to listen to what other people have to say, as it gives us a lot of valuable information in terms of what they like or didn’t like about each amaretto extract – we’d way rather use something that has amazing reviews rather than something with bad reviews, right?
- Track record: A brand’s reputation is everything, as it’s reflected in their products. That’s why we look for transparent ingredient lists, great customer service, and a lack of scandals!
- Price: We have amaretto extracts that are budget-friendly or that will lighten your wallet – there’s something for everyone!
Now, let’s get right into the rankings!
#1 Best Overall: OliveNation
Our number 1 spot for the best overall amaretto extract goes to OliveNation!
These guys are no strangers to the top spot in our “bests” lists, and they’ve once again taken it for their truly amazing amaretto extract! It’s natural, delicious, and boasts wonderfully balanced flavors. OliveNation’s amaretto extract is made from almond and apricot kernels, giving it an almondy taste with unique undertones!
Plus, you get this amazing amaretto extract for an amazing price – it costs just $2.28 per fluid ounce, making it the most budget-friendly option on this list!
Give this one a try – you definitely won’t regret it!
Ingredients: Water, alcohol, propylene glycol & natural flavors.
#2 Best GMO-Free: Native Vanilla
At our number 2 spot we have Native Vanilla!
Native Vanilla is a really great brand – not only do they make some great flavoring agents, but they also only use natural and sustainable products. Their amaretto extract is absolutely delicious, with the added benefit of being kosher-certified and GMO-free. This makes it an awesome choice, as you get a delicious flavoring product all while being health-conscious!
And, you support a small business that takes care of nature, all for the amazing price of $2.50 per fluid ounce!
Try this one out!
Ingredients: Alcohol, Water, Natural Oil of Bitter Almond, and Vanilla Beans.
#3 Best Kosher: Vanilla Bean Kings
Vanilla Bean Kings is an awesome brand – they’re consistently in our “bests” lists, and have some amazing flavoring agents!
Their amaretto extract is no different. It has a wonderful balance of tastes, providing that unique nutty flavor to many of your dishes in a natural and effective package! Plus, this amaretto extract is kosher-certified, as well as non-GMO, gluten-free, and sugar-free!
On top of all that, you’ll support a brand that crafts their products in the USA, which is always something we’re a fan of!
Give it a go!
Ingredients: Alcohol, Water, Natural Oil of Bitter Almond, and Select Madagascar Vanilla Beans.
#4 Honorable Mention: Beanilla
We want to give a shout-out to Beanilla, who has created a solid amaretto extract!
Beanilla’s amaretto extract offers an awesome blend of flavors, giving you a smooth tasting extract that is both gluten-free and kosher. It’s on par with a lot of the amaretto extracts on this list, however it’s less popular – there aren’t any reviews for it.
That doesn’t mean it’s not a great option however, as we’ve found it to be a wonderful addition to the pantry! In fact, we think you’ll like so much that you’ll want to add your own review for others to see!
Ingredients: Natural flavors, alcohol and water.
#5 Best Organic: Nature’s Flavors
Taking the spot for best organic amaretto extract is Nature’s Flavors!
We really like organic flavoring agents, as they offer a great way to escape the additives in many other products. However, they often have issues with taste…
Well, that’s not the case here – Nature’s Flavors’ amaretto extract is organic AND delicious! It has an awesome flavor that’s powerful and tasty, and matches the deliciousness of the other extracts on this list. However, it is quite a bit more expensive, coming in at $9.88 per fluid ounce – yes, that’s pricey, but you won’t find a better organic amaretto extract!
Give it a shot!
Ingredients: Organic Cane Alcohol and Natural Flavors.
#6 Best Keto: Amoretti
The best keto amaretto extract comes from Amoretti.
The name of the brand is very fitting for the product, and you’ll find that they’ve earned calling themselves after their star product! Amoretti’s amaretto extract has an awesome flavor profile that’ll add that special taste to anything you pair it with – all in a keto-friendly package!
Plus, it has no preservatives, no artificial colors, is gluten-free, vegan-friendly, and is kosher-certified to boot!
However, it’s the most expensive product on this list, coming in at $17.18 per fluid ounce. That’s a tough pill to swallow, and I recommend looking at some other extracts on this list just for the price. But, if you want a keto-friendly amaretto extract, you won’t find a better one than Amoretti’s!
Ingredients: Natural amaretto flavor (flavor contains vegetable glycerin).
Other’s we reviewed
With the many great amaretto extracts come some not-so-great ones…
LorAnn, for example, is a brand that’s extremely popular – and for good reason, as they make some great flavoring agents!
However, their amaretto extract isn’t an extract at all – it’s actually an emulsion, which just means that it’s water based instead of alcohol based. Now, that’s not a bad thing at all, and mainly just makes changes in the boiling points – the flavor in emulsions doesn’t get as baked-out as the flavor in extracts does.
The bad thing about LorAnn’s amaretto flavoring product is that it uses artificial flavors, which we at Coconut Mama don’t support. Why get something fake, when the real thing is so much better? Therefore, we don’t recommend LorAnn in this case, but we encourage you to take a look at the many great options in the rankings above!
Links on this page may be affiliate links, for which the site earns a small commission, but the price for you is the same
Leave a Comment