There’s something about the combination of hazelnuts and chocolate that’s just pure magic. But as much as I love Nutella, I don’t love its high sugar content and the fillers it contains.
Whether you’re looking for a healthier alternative, a nut-free option, or just something different, I’ve curated a list of my top Nutella alternatives!
8 Best nutella alternatives
- Homemade nutella
- Chocolate almond butter
- Chocolate sunflower seed butter
- Chocolate peanut butter
- Chocolate coconut butter
- Vanilla hazelnut butter
- Salted caramel nut butter
- Cookie butter
Best nutella alternative: Make it at home
The best Nutella alternative is to make it at home. Check out this fantastic recipe here. This homemade version is creamy, rich, and free from unnecessary additives. The best part? You have the freedom to choose your preferred sweetener, making it keto-friendly if that’s your jam. Plus, by using coconut milk instead of skimmed milk, it’s a win for our vegan friends too.
Best low-calorie nutella alternative: Chocolate almond butter
Almond butter tends to be lower in calories compared to traditional Nutella, and when combined with cocoa, it delivers that rich chocolatey flavor without the guilt. Plus, almond butter contains fewer carbs and sugars than Nutella. Look for minimal added sugars and no hydrogenated oils.
Best nut-free nutella alternative: Chocolate sunflower seed butter
For those with nut allergies, chocolate sunflower seed butter is a lifesaver. It’s completely nut-free and still delivers that delightful chocolatey goodness. Plus, sunflower seeds are packed with nutrients, making this a healthier option without compromising on taste.
Best nutella alternative for breakfast: Chocolate peanut butter
When it comes to breakfast, chocolate peanut butter is my go-to Nutella alternative. It’s perfect for spreading on toast, crepes, waffles, or stirring into hot oatmeal. One of my favorites (especially for smoothies) is PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter with Cocoa. It’s lower in fat and calories but still incredibly delicious.
Best nutella substitute for baking: Chocolate coconut butter
For baking, chocolate coconut butter is unbeatable. I recently made a chocolate layer cake with a cocoa hazelnut spread as the filling, and it was unreal. But I think chocolate coconut butter would be just as amazing! The velvety smooth texture of chocolate coconut butter makes it ideal for cake fillings, macaroons, these chocolate hazelnut cups, or any dessert that calls for a luxurious chocolate spread. Plus, the subtle coconut flavor adds an extra layer of richness.
Chocolate-free nutella alternative: Vanilla hazelnut butter
Sometimes, you might want to skip the chocolate and enjoy the pure taste of hazelnuts. Vanilla hazelnut butter is a fantastic chocolate-free alternative. You can also find cashew-hazelnut vanilla butter, which offers a creamy, slightly sweet spread that’s perfect for a more subtle flavor.
Best nutella alternative with fruit: Salted caramel nut butter
When pairing with fruit, salted caramel nut butter is my top pick. The combination of salty and sweet compliments fresh fruit beautifully. Try it with apple slices, bananas, or even drizzled over a fruit salad for a decadent treat.
Best nutella alternative for flavor: Cookie butter
For sheer flavor, cookie butter is a winner. Yes, it’s as delicious as it sounds. It tastes like a blend of gingerbread, caramel, and cinnamon. I love using cookie butter as a spread on toast, pancakes, or waffles, and it’s also fantastic as a dip for fruit or pretzels. Sometimes, I even swirl it into oatmeal or use it as an ingredient in baking for an extra touch of sweetness.
FAQs
Yes, several brands offer cleaner versions of Nutella with fewer additives and lower sugar content. See our list of the top Nutella alternatives you can buy! Making it at home is also a great way to ensure it’s clean.
Yes, Kraft hazelnut spread is healthier than Nutella, as it doesn’t contain palm oil and has less sugar than Nutella.
Nutiva is a healthier alternative to Nutella, as it uses organic ingredients and has lower sugar content. It’s also free from palm oil.
Leave a Comment