With so many nut butter options out there these days, it’s getting harder and harder to pick one out at the grocery store.
So, in this article we’ll be comparing pecan butter and almond butter, diving into what makes each one of them better or worse from the other so that you can choose the right one for yourself!
Comparing pecan butter vs almond butter
|Rich, buttery, slightly sweet
|Nutty, rich, slightly sweet
|Slightly grainy and runny (or crunchy)
|Glycemic index (GI)
What is pecan butter?
Pecan butter is made from roasted or toasted pecans (this enhances their flavor), which are blended into a creamy spread with a smooth texture.
There are usually no added preservatives, making pecans the only real ingredient you need to make pecan butter at home!
What is almond butter?
Almond butter is made by blending roasted almonds together into a rich, creamy, and smooth spread.
It can be as crunchy or smooth as you want, coming in all sorts of “crunchiness” levels. It’s generally slightly grainy due to the almonds, and sticky!
Almond butter is a popular substitute for peanut butter, becoming a staple in many nut butter users’ pantries!
Differences between pecan butter and almond butter
Pecan butter has more of a buttery flavor, while almond butter has a nuttier flavor. Pecan butter is smooth and creamy, while almond butter’s texture is more grainy (depending on the “crunchiness”) and slightly runny – it also tends to be stickier than pecan butter.
Pecan butter tends to be less oily than almond butter, meaning you won’t have to stir it up before you can use it – this applies to the natural versions of each butter (the more processed versions usually have hydrogenated oils which don’t separate easily).
That being said, the textures, flavors, and consistencies can vary from brand-to-brand for both nut butters!
How to use pecan butter vs almond butter
Pecan butter’s rich and buttery flavor pairs perfectly as a spread on things like pancakes, toast, and waffles. It’s also great as an ingredient in sweet bakes!
You can also use it in a marinade for meats or as a base for salad dressing if you want to add a rich, slightly nutty twist to your dish!
Almond butter is also a great spread for toast, bakes, and more! You can throw it into your smoothie, mix it into your pasta, or use it to make a dessert like this almond butter banana ice cream!
Nutrition: Pecan butter vs almond butter
Pecan butter and almond butter are quite similar on paper, with both having a healthy amount of unsaturated fats (which are good for controlling cholesterol levels), low sugar (pecan butter has 0 grams!), and similar calories.
Almond butter does have a higher fiber, vitamin E, and protein content, making it a great choice for an after-workout smoothie!
Also, almond butter has less net carbs than pecan butter, making it slightly more suitable for a low-carb or keto diet.
|Serving size: 2 tbsp
|Total fat (saturated)
|18 g (2 g)
|17 g (2 g)
|Net carbs (fiber)
|4 g (~2 g)
|3 g (4 g)
|Total sugars (incl. added)
|1 g (0 g)
How to store pecan butter and almond butter
Both pecan butter and almond butter are sensitive to light and heat – especially the natural variety of the butters. Put them in the fridge to avoid having them go rancid, increasing their shelf-life.
Nut butters generally last 2-3 months in the fridge, but that can vary from brand-to-brand – be sure to check the label for specific storage instructions!
Pecan butter vs almond butter: Which is better
These two are going at it neck-and-neck – it’s hard to see a clear winner!
Both pecan butter and almond butter are delicious choices, with similar nutritional profiles. Pecan butter gives you a buttery, velvety, rich taste, while almond butter offers a nuttier, grainy, slightly sweet flavor that also goes great in many dishes!
It basically comes down to preference – I recommend switching these out for one another in different recipes/spreads to see which one you like more!
These two nut butters have slight differences in their flavors and textures, but can be switched out with one another easily to customize your dishes the way you want!
Pecan butter has a nice blend of minerals, vitamins, and monounsaturated fats which all contribute to overall health! That being said, nut butters are calorie-dense in general, so enjoy pecan butter in moderation.
Almond butter tends to be on the runny side – however, you can store it in the fridge to thicken it up a bit!