Water kefir and Kombucha are both fermented drinks, meaning they’re made by adding particular types of bacteria and yeast to liquids and letting them do their thing. The bacteria and yeast feed on the sugars, which causes fermentation. This fermentation changes the taste and texture of the drink.
Kombucha may be the more popular of the two, but is it the best option? Let’s compare.
Comparing Water Kefir vs Kombucha
| Kombucha | Water Kefir | |
| Substitution ratio | n/a | n/a |
| Gluten-free? | yes | yes |
| Keto-friendly? | In moderation | In moderation |
| Paleo-friendly? | Sometimes | Sometimes |
| Common Allergens | Depends on added ingredients | Depends on added ingredients |
| Pantry shelf life (unopened/sealed) | 1-3 months | 3 months |
Differences Between Water Kefir And Kombucha
Water kefir and kombucha are both fizzy drinks that are great for your gut, but they’re made differently and have different “good guys” (bacteria) inside them. While both drinks are made through fermentation, they differ in their base ingredients (water or coconut water versus tea), the type of bacteria/yeast used (kefir grains versus SCOBY), and the length of the fermentation process (1-2 days for kefir, several days to weeks for kombucha).
Kombucha brewing uses a SCOBY, which has more yeast and bacteria that make acetic acid. Acetic acid is what gives kombucha its sour taste. Water kefir uses grains that have less yeast and more bacteria that produce lactic acid, giving it a different kind of tangy flavor. In simple words, kombucha has more yeast than bacteria, while water kefir has more bacteria than yeast.
Kombucha is known for its postbiotic benefits, meaning it helps your body get the most out of the food you eat. Water kefir not only has these postbiotic benefits but also probiotics, the friendly bacteria that help keep your gut healthy.
Different kinds of bacteria live in water kefir and kombucha. In water kefir, you’ll find bacteria like Lactobacillus, Bifidobacterium, Pediococcus, and Leuconostoc. In kombucha, you’ll find Pediococcus, Acetobacter, Saccharomyces, Gluconacetobacter, and Brettanomyces.
Taste and Culinary Uses
Water kefir is typically made with water, sugar, and kefir grains. These aren’t actual grains like wheat or rice but small, rubbery-looking bits that contain the bacteria and yeast needed for fermentation. The result is a sweet, lightly carbonated, and slightly sour drink that’s packed with probiotics.
Kombucha, on the other hand, is made with tea, sugar, and something called a SCOBY (which stands for “Symbiotic Culture Of Bacteria and Yeast”). This is a gelatinous blob that contains the bacteria and yeast necessary for fermentation. The end result is a tangy, vinegary, fizzy drink that contains organic acids, vitamins, and enzymes.
Are Water Kefir and Kombucha Substitutes for Each Other?
The taste of kombucha and the taste of water kefir are completely different from each other, so in that sense, no, they do not make suitable substitutes for each other in recipes. However, if you are simply looking for a beverage to help improve your gut function and health, then yes, they are both great, and you can mix and match all you want!
Nutritional Profile And Health Benefits
Kombucha is packed with beneficial compounds that can vary depending on how it’s brewed and what ingredients are used. One of the key components is acetic acid, produced during fermentation, which aids digestion and may protect against harmful bacteria. It also contains B vitamins essential for energy production and maintaining overall health.
Kombucha is also low in calories and carbs, largely because the SCOBY consumes most of the initial sugar during fermentation. However, commercial kombuchas may contain added sugars or fruit juices, increasing their calorie and sugar content. Kombucha is rich in probiotics, beneficial bacteria that promote a healthy gut and aid digestion. The specific probiotics present can vary based on the brewing process and the bacteria involved.
On the other hand, water kefir is a lighter, bubbly beverage made by fermenting sugar water with kefir grains. It’s an excellent choice for those limiting animal product consumption as it doesn’t require any dairy, unlike traditional kefir. This versatile drink can be flavored with a variety of fruits, veggies, herbs, or spices, making it an appealing substitute for high-calorie beverages like soda or juice.
Water kefir not only helps reduce calorie intake but also supports weight loss, immunity, and gut health. It’s a powerhouse of probiotics, boasting a diversity of beneficial bacteria. Research suggests that water kefir could contain up to 56 different strains of yeast and bacteria, contributing to its reputation as one of the best dietary sources of probiotics. These probiotics enhance gut health, stimulate the immune system, and may even combat cancer cells.
Diet Suitability
Despite being health tonics, both these drinks are pretty complicated when it comes to their suitability in diets. Let’s look at a few.
Keto
If you’re planning to incorporate kombucha into your low-carb lifestyle, it’s important to carefully review labels and serving sizes before purchasing any store-bought options. How much kombucha is acceptable while following a keto diet? With diligent macro counting, it’s recommended to occasionally consume no more than a half serving of kombucha with lower carb content. This would typically amount to approximately 3.5 grams of carbohydrates. Water kefir is also keto-friendly but only in moderation. You need to watch your sugar consumption and stick to a single serving size.
Paleo
There is a lot of debate in the paleo community regarding both kefir and kombucha. While many believe dairy-based kefir is off the menu, others say it is okay because the fermentation process reduces the lactose. Water kefir contains no dairy, so it’s a safer choice for paleo dieters, even though it wasn’t really a ‘thing’ in the Paleolithic era. But, it is also usually brewed with cane sugar, which is a paleo no-no. Same with kombucha. The cane sugar component is technically not paleo, but as the fermentation lowers the sugar content, many say it’s okay. Use your best judgment on this one, I guess!
Whole30
According to the rules of the Whole30 program, any product with added sugar in its ingredient list is not suitable for consumption during the diet. However, when it comes to kombucha and water kefir, things can get a bit tricky. Both require some sugar for fermentation, which is not technically an ‘added sugar.’ Commercially available kombucha typically uses conventional sugars, like white or cane sugar, but some brands use fruit juice as the sugar source. So, in this case, it is best to go for brands that explicitly state they are Whole30 approved.
Vegan
Both water kefir and kombucha are brewed with sugar, and if it is with white cane sugar processed with bone char, it may not be considered appropriate for the vegan diet. If brewed with vegan-certified sugar, then you are in the clear!
Gluten-Free
Rejoice! Both kombucha and water kefir are naturally gluten-free. While kefir is brewed with things called grains, those grains are not from a gluten-containing source.
How to Store Water Kefir and Kombucha
Both water kefir and kombucha need to be kept refrigerated at all times. Why? Because both of these drinks are living beverages, and they continue to ferment even when bottled. Keeping them cool will ensure that the process slows down and you don’t end up with an overly-fermented product.
Price and Availability
Kombucha is more readily available than water kefir at the moment, as it is much more well-known and trendy! But water kefir, particularly coconut water kefir, is getting there. In terms of price, it varies greatly by brand, but they are around the same price. This is surprising as water kefir is cheaper to make.
Water Kefir vs. Kombucha: The Ultimate Verdict
Honestly, the winner in this showdown depends on your tastebuds as well as the health benefits you are looking for. I personally love kombucha, but my husband can’t stand the vinegar taste and prefers water kefir. So, it is a draw! Maybe a morning booch and an evening kefir?
FAQs
Both beverages start with a sugar source for fermentation, but the final sugar content can vary significantly. The fermentation process reduces the sugar content in both drinks, but some commercial kombuchas may have additional sugar or fruit juice added after fermentation.
Many people find water kefir easier to brew because it ferments faster (usually in 24-48 hours) compared to kombucha (which generally takes 7-30 days).
As with any fermented food or drink, it’s best to start with small amounts to see how your body responds. Some people may experience digestive discomfort if they consume too much at once. Also, due to the slight alcohol content produced during fermentation, pregnant and breastfeeding individuals should consult their healthcare provider before consuming these beverages.
Leave a Comment