Revealed: The Best Tiramisu Syrup You Can Buy

If you love the traditional Italian dessert tiramisu, you’ll love to hear that you don’t have to limit yourself to enjoying the flavor in just that! 

Tiramisu syrup is a wonderful flavoring agent that you can use to make delicious beverages – your cocktails and coffees are about to get a massive upgrade! It’s delicious and extremely convenient, giving you all the wonderful flavors of tiramisu in an easy-to-use syrup form. 

That being said, not all tiramisu syrups are created equal. There are definitely some that you’ll want to avoid, while there are some that you have to try if you want the absolute best…

We’ve tested a bunch of them, and have created this list ranking our favorite ones! That way, you can get right to making some delicious concoctions rather than spending time trying out different ones.

Let’s check out the best tiramisu syrups you can buy!

What is tiramisu syrup?

Tiramisu syrup is like that delicious Italian dessert in a liquid form. It boasts the amazing blend of coffee, lady fingers, custard, cocoa, and rum flavors, giving you an authentic tasting syrup. 

This syrup isn’t made by blending up tiramisu, but is rather made by boiling sugar and water together into a syrup, and then combining multiple ingredients that together create the delicious tiramisu flavor! Many brands use artificial ingredients to make this happen, but the best tiramisu syrups use natural ingredients – which we’ll show you in just a bit!

How to use tiramisu syrup for flavoring

You can use tiramisu syrup for several things, but it’s best used as a flavoring agent in beverages. 

For example, you can add it to your morning coffee for a delicious flavor twist, or even sweeten your tea with it! If you want to get fancy, there are many tiramisu-inspired lattes, gourmet coffees, and cocktails that you can make. 

Plus, adding a touch to your smoothies is another way to enjoy the delicious flavor! 

Add about 1-2 tablespoons of tiramisu syrup to most standard beverages for a well-balanced flavor. Now, this may take some experimenting until you get a flavor that you like – but it’s well worth it! 

You can also pour it over your ice cream, mix it into your oatmeal, or even put it on your pancakes and waffles for a delicious twist! I recommend combining it with chocolate dishes or beverages, as the unique flavor of tiramisu really elevates those!

Top recipes for tiramisu syrup

Try your tiramisu syrup in things like: 

• Keto tiramisu: This is a delicious tiramisu that will fit your keto diet needs! It uses coconut flour for a nice tropical twist, and can be enhanced with some tiramisu syrup! Either mix it into the cream layer or pour some over top of the finished dessert – not all tiramisu syrup is keto-friendly, so be aware of that!
• Coconut milk coffee latte: Tiramisu syrup is the perfect addition to any of your favorite lattes! This specific coconut milk one will elevate itself with about 1-2 tablespoons of tiramisu syrup, getting a boost in coffee, cocoa, and rum flavors that pair perfectly with coconut!
• Chocolate coconut milk ice cream: Another coconut-inspired dish, this ice cream already combines the delicious chocolate and coconut flavors, and is greatly enhanced with tiramisu syrup poured over top! Think about it – cocoa, chocolate, coconut, custard…there are a lot of delicious flavors starting with the letter “c” in this one!

How to choose the best tiramisu syrup

You want to be sure you’re getting a tiramisu syrup that actually tastes like tiramisu without being artificial or over-the-top – that’s why some research and testing is required! Lucky for you, we’ve done all that, and also made this list of criteria that helps us find the best syrups:

1. Ingredients: Natural ingredients are always the way to go, as they provide the highest-quality of flavors and textures. Plus, it feels good to avoid artificial ingredients. 
2. Consumer feedback: People talk, and it’s important to listen. Customer reviews leave a great amount of info that’s important to consider when deciding which syrups are good or bad.
3. Track record: A brand should always strive to be transparent, provide great customer support, and consistently make high-quality products – and that’s exactly what we look for.
4. Price: Tiramisu syrups are quite affordable, and we’ve included a range of prices so that there’s something for everyone!

With all that said, let’s jump into the rankings!

#1 Best Overall: Monin

Our best overall tiramisu syrup comes from Monin! 

Monin is a consistent name in the syrup business, making favorites for bartenders and amateur drink mixers alike. Their tiramisu syrup boasts a wonderful flavor, giving you the impression that you’re eating ground-up tiramisu (but in a smoother package)! Plus, it’s made with natural ingredients!

The accurate flavor is further complemented by its price, coming in at $0.68 per fluid ounce – that’s a great price for a wonderful syrup!

Level up your beverages with this one!

Ingredients: Sugar, water, natural flavoring, acid: citric acid.

#2 Runner-Up: Torani

The runner-up is the tiramisu extract from Torani!

Torani and Monin often go head-to-head in any flavoring syrup showdown, with Monin squeaking out with the win here! Torani’s tiramisu syrup is also absolutely delicious, and a wonderful ingredient to anything you want! 

Your coffees and lattes will enjoy a bold tiramisu flavor that’s accurate and tasty! It’s a bit more expensive than number 1, costing $0.79 per fluid ounce. However, it’s the most reviewed tiramisu syrup on this list with over 350 reviews!

You can’t go wrong with Torani here!

Ingredients: Pure cane sugar, water, natural flavors, citric acid, sodium benzoate and potassium sorbate (to preserve freshness).

#3 Honorable Mention: Amoretti

Rounding out our list is Amoretti!

These guys have been becoming more and more popular, and directly compete with the flavoring giants Torani and Monin here! Amoretti tiramisu syrup offers a wonderful blend of flavors, giving you a great way to add the tiramisu flavor to your favorite desserts and beverages!

Plus, it’s the most affordable on this list (although all are very close in price), costing you just $0.62 per fluid ounce!

Give this one a try!

Ingredients: Milk, sucrose, dextrose, fructose, water, natural flavor, caramel color.

Others we reviewed

While there are some great tiramisu syrups, some didn’t make the cut…

DaVinci Gourmet offers a kosher tiramisu syrup – which is great! However, they used artificial ingredients, including flavoring, which is unfortunate. They’re a popular brand, but we don’t recommend anything with artificial ingredients when there are great natural options available – like in the list above!

1883 is another brand that didn’t make the cut due to using artificial flavoring – natural ingredients just provide a much better flavor and a higher-quality experience, so we don’t need to settle for fake stuff.

That all said, try out any of the ones in our rankings – we think you’ll love them!

Links on this page may be affiliate links, for which the site earns a small commission, but the price for you is the same